Summary
The pufferfish
Tetraodon nigroviridis has a genome of 350 Mb,
the smallest genome known to date in the vertebrates. This
characteristic makes it very attractive for genomic studies, and
inspired the launching of a sequencing project at Genoscope in 1997,
the year that the center opened. The initial objective of Genoscope
was to compare the genomic sequences of this fish to that of humans to
help in the annotation of human genes and to estimate their
number. This strategy is based on the common genetic heritage of the
vertebrates: from one species of vertebrate to another, even for those
as far apart as a fish and a mammal, the same genes are present for
the most part. In the case of the "compact" genome of
Tetraodon, this common complement of genes is contained in a
genome eight times smaller than that of humans. Although the length of
the exons is similar in these two species, the size of the introns and
the intergenic sequences is greatly reduced in this fish. Furthermore,
these regions, in contrast to the exons, have diverged completely
since the separation of the lineages leading to humans and
Tetraodon. The Exofish method, developed at Genoscope, exploits this
contrast such that the conserved regions which can be identified by
comparing genomic sequences of the two species, correspond only to
coding regions. Using preliminary sequencing results of the genome of
Tetraodon in the year 2000, Genoscope evaluated the number of
human genes at about 30,000, whereas much higher estimations were
current. The progress of the annotation of the human genome has since
supported the Genoscope hypothesis, with values as low as 22,000 genes
and a consensus of around 25,000 genes.
The sequencing of the
Tetraodon genome at a depth of about 8X,
carried out as a collaboration between Genoscope and the Whitehead
Institute Center for Genome Research (now the Broad Institute), was
finished in 2002, with the production of an assembly covering 90% of
the euchromatic region of the genome of the fish. This has permitted
the application of Exofish at a larger scale in comparisons with the
genome of humans, but also with those of the two other vertebrates
sequenced at the time (Takifugu, a fish closely related to
Tetraodon, and the mouse). The conserved regions detected in
this way have been integrated into the annotation procedure, along
with other resources (cDNA sequences from
Tetraodon and
ab
initio predictions). Of the 28,000 genes annotated, some families
were examined in detail: selenoproteins, and Type 1 cytokines and
their receptors. The comparison of the proteome of
Tetraodon
with those of mammals has revealed some interesting differences, such
as a major diversification of some hormone systems and of the collagen
molecules in the fish.
A search for transposable elements in the genomic sequences of
Tetraodon has also revealed a high diversity (75 types), which
contrasts with their scarcity; the small size of the
Tetraodon
genome is due to the low abundance of these elements, of which some
appear to still be active. Another factor in the compactness of the
Tetraodon genome, which has been confirmed by annotation, is
the reduction in intron size, which approaches a lower limit of 50-60
bp, and which preferentially affects certain genes.
The availability of the sequences from the genomes of humans and mice
on one hand, and Takifugu and
Tetraodon on the other, provide
new opportunities for the study of vertebrate evolution. We have shown
that the level of neutral evolution is higher in fish than in
mammals. The protein sequences of fish also diverge more quickly than
those of mammals. A key mechanism in evolution is gene duplication,
which we have studied by taking advantage of the anchoring of the
majority of the sequences from the assembly on the chromosomes. The
result of this study speaks strongly in favor of a whole genome
duplication event, very early in the line of ray-finned fish
(Actinopterygians). An even stronger evidence came from synteny
studies between the genomes of humans and
Tetraodon. Using a
high-resolution synteny map, we have reconstituted the genome of the
vertebrate which predates this duplication - that is, the last common
ancestor to all bony vertebrates (most of the vertebrates apart from
cartilaginous fish and agnaths like lamprey). This ancestral karyotype
contains 12 chromosomes, and the 21
Tetraodon chromosomes
derive from it by the whole genome duplication and a surprisingly
small number of interchromosomal rearrangements. On the contrary,
exchanges between chromosomes have been much more frequent in the
lineage that leads to humans. All these results are presented in an
article
published in the 21th October 2004 issue of
Nature.
Up
The ecology and systematic position of
Tetraodon nigroviridis
Tetraodon nigroviridis is a little fish (less than 10
centimeters long in captivity) which is popular with tropical fish
fanciers. In its natural state, it is found in rivers and streams of
Southeast Asia (Indonesia, Indochina, Malaysia, the Philippines), as
well as in estuaries and mangrove swamps, and even occasionally in the
sea; it is therefore not strictly limited to fresh water. Tetraodon
nigroviridis belongs to the family of "smooth" pufferfish
(Tetraodontidae) and, at a higher systematic level, to the order
Tetraodontiforms, which also includes the diodons or "spiny"
pufferfish (Diodontidae), sunfishes (Molidae), boxfishes (Ostraciidae)
and triggerfishes (Balistidae), among others. Tetraodon
nigroviridis is often confused with a closely-related species,
Tetraodon fluviatilis. Genoscope has found molecular markers
which can differentiate between the two species (access
to this data and phylogenetic results). Other members of the
Tetraodontid family are fugus, salt water fish for which one species,
Takifugu rubripes, was also the target of a sequencing project
(see below). The Tetraodon nigroviridis and Takifugu
rubripes lines diverged 18 to 30 million years ago.
Up
Pufferfish, vertebrates with a compact
genome
Interest in the Tetraodontids was kindled in 1968 when
R. Hinegardner discovered the very small size
of their genomes; in particular, this author showed that the genome of
Tetraodon, with a size grossly estimated at 380 Mb (by
measuring the DNA content of the cells), was the smallest of the 300
genomes of teleost fishes measured, and consequently the smallest
vertebrate genome known. As a comparison, the zebrafish,
Danio
rerio, which is used as a model organism in genomics and genetics,
has a genome of 1.6 billion base pairs, four times larger than that of
Tetraodon. The human genome, which contains 3.2 billion base
pairs, is eight times larger than that of
Tetraodon. Following
this discovery,
Sydney Brenner and his
colleagues at Cambridge confirmed the small size of the genome of
another pufferfish, the fugu
Takifugu rubripes, which they
estimated to be 400 Mb by using a partial random sequencing
approach. This early sequence data further confirmed the hypothesis of
the compactness of the pufferfish genome; since the majority of the
functions present in other vertebrates are found in teleost fish, it
was reasonable to suppose that fish and mammals possess a more or less
comparable repertoire of genes. It was therefore expected that the
small size of the pufferfish genome was not due to a large reduction
in the number of genes compared to mammals, but to a reduction in
non-coding sequences. The first sequences obtained by Brenner
confirmed this: they revealed the small size of introns and intergenic
regions of fugu, resulting from the scarcity of repeated sequences. It
is in this sense that this genome, which is dense in exons, is called
"compact". The structure of the genes themselves appeared conserved:
in the few cases studied the introns were found in similar positions
in the Takifugu gene and in the orthologous gene in humans. A
preliminary analysis of the Tetraodon
nigroviridis genome, published in 2000, demonstrated the same
rarity of repeated sequences.
Up
Hypotheses about compact genomes
How can this compactness of the pufferfish genome be explained? The
analysis of partial genomic sequences from
Tetraodon
nigroviridis and
Takifugu rubripes has provided some of the
answers. Transposable elements, which constitute the majority of
repeated sequences, represent 45% of the sequence of the human genome,
whereas they are very scarce in pufferfish: they represent only 3.8%
of the assembly of the genomic sequence of
Tetraodon
nigroviridis and 2.7% of the Takifugu assembly. These are the
smallest values known in multicellular eukaryotes, even if the true
abundance of transposable elements in these two fish is most likely a
little higher; they are in fact concentrated in the heterochromatic
regions of the
Tetraodon genome (
Dasilva
et al., 2002), and therefore underrepresented in the
assembly. Although rare, the transposable elements are characterized
by high diversity in
Tetraodon. It is possible that the
transposable elements and other sequences which have no functional
constraints have a higher level of deletion in these fish, which seems
to be confirmed by the fact that pseudogenes are eliminated more
rapidly in
Tetraodon than in humans. Another factor which could
explain the compact genomes of the Tetraodontids is a high resistance
to insertions which may be inherent to this lineage, as suggested by a
comparative study with diodons and a sunfish (
Neafsey and Palumbi, 2003). The size of the
genomes of pufferfish may have increased more slowly than it did in
other Tetraodontiform lineages, or, more probably, may have
experienced a reduction during evolution. At any rate, these animals
constitute an excellent model for understanding the factors which
determine the evolution in size of genomes.
Up
The compact genome of Tetraodon nigroviridis,
a model for the study of vertebrate genomes
Sydney Brenner was the first to express an interest in a compact
genome such as that of Takifugu as a tool for the study of other
vertebrate genomes. In 1993 he proposed to sequence all or part of the
genome of fugu in order to access the repertoire of vertebrate genes
at the lowest cost possible. By sequencing a given quantity of DNA in
a pufferfish, there is a much better chance of finding an exon than by
sequencing the same quantity of DNA in another vertebrate, especially
in mammals such as humans. Sequencing at moderate coverage is thus
sufficient to get a good idea of the gene content in a compact
genome. Furthermore, the rarity of repeated sequences makes a random
shotgun sequencing strategy possible, which is rapid and economic, but
is not suitable for a genome which is as vast and complex as the human
genome.
Despite these arguments, the fugu project did not get off the ground
immediately. It had not yet obtained financial support by 1997, and
its realization seemed problematic. Genoscope therefore decided to
undertake the sequencing of another fish with a compact genome in
order to make a "model vertebrate genome" available to the scientific
community.
Tetradodon nigroviridis was chosen on account of its
small size, ease of maintenance in a fresh-water aquarium and its
availability in the tropical fish fancier milieu, whereas
Takifugu
rubripes, which is found in the coastal waters of China and the
Japanese archipelago, is difficult to import. Furthermore, large tanks
of sea water are needed to maintain fugu which may attain several
kilograms.
Tetraodon nigroviridis is therefore more suitable
for molecular analyses in which the biological material must be easily
and constantly accessible (
Crnogorac-Jurcevic
et al., 1997).
Following Genoscope's first publications on the genomic sequences of
Tetraodon in the year 2000, the importance of sequencing a
small genome for the analysis of the human genome was demonstrated. At
this moment,
the sequencing project
for Takifugu rubripes was initiated, resulting
in the publication of a draft genome sequence in 2002 (45,000 contigs
assembled in more than 12,000 scaffolds covering 332.5 Mb, for a total
genome size estimated at 365 Mb) (
Aparicio et
al., 2002). The comparison of predicted proteins in the fugu
sequence with human proteins revealed strong correspondences for
three-quarters of them, which validated the initial hypothesis of a
comparable repertoire of genes in all vertebrates.
The
Tetraodon and Takifugu projects are less redundant than
they appear. Comparisons of the genomic sequences of two pufferfish
separated by 18 to 30 million years enables improvement of the
annotation on both sides, which reinforces the utility of these model
genomes.
Up
Exofish, a tool for comparative genomics
The principal objective of the sequencing of the
Tetraodon
genome, at the beginning of the project, was to compare the genomic
sequences of this fish with those of humans in order to facilitate the
identification of human genes. This comparative genomics approach is
based on a simple hypothesis: during the 400 million years that have
passed since the separation of the
Tetraodon and Mammals
lineages, the genomic regions which are constrained by their
function - especially the coding sequences - have accumulated fewer
mutations and thus diverged more slowly than the other regions. The
evolutionary distance which separates us from this fish is
sufficiently large to ensure that the introns and intergenic regions
will have diverged completely, but is sufficiently short such that the
majority of coding sequences will have been conserved for at least
part of their length. This contrast thus makes it possible to identify
them by comparisons at the whole genome scale (a different use of the
genome than that chosen later in the Takifugu project, in which the
human-fish comparison was limited to predicted genes).
For this purpose, Genoscope has developed a comparative genomics tool
called Exofish (for EXOn Finding by Sequence Homology), based on the
BLAST algorithm (
Frequently
Asked Questions about Exofish). A comparison between genomic
sequences of the fish and the target human sequence produces Ecores
(Evolutionary COnserved REgions), which are alignments of
Tetraodon sequences with conserved regions in the human
genome. A calibration makes it possible to define the parameters for
optimizing specificity (conditions under which no ecore will be found
in the introns of known human genes) without compromising sensitivity
(the percentage of human exons detected).
Up
An estimation of the number of human genes using
Exofish
Exofish was utilized for the first time in 2000, when only 33% of the
sequence of
Tetraodon and 42% of the human genome sequence had
been determined. The goal of this comparison was to evaluate the
number of human genes; at this time very different values had been
proposed. The principle of the evaluation was simple: the number of
ecores obtained on a partial sequence of the human genome was
extrapolated to the ensemble of the genome, then divided by the
average number of ecores per gene (as measured on a reference
collection of human genes). This calculation led to an estimation of
the number of human genes of 28 000 to 34 000 (see a
press
release). This result, which was published in 2000 (
Roest Crollius et al., 2000), was in
agreement with another estimate published at the same time, but which
was based on a different principle (
B. Ewing &
P. Green, 2000). However, it was much less than the estimates that
were current at the time: the human genome had been reported to
contain from 50 000 to 90 000 genes, and some researchers believed
that our genome contained at least 200 000 genes! Many were surprised
by this drop in the estimation of the number of genes, because it
indicated that humans had barely twice the number of genes of the
fruit fly. Since the completion of the sequencing of the human genome
in April 2003, the Genoscope's estimate has been confirmed by progress
in annotation: automatic annotation procedures such as Ensembl,
Twinscan or SGP2 have identified between 22 000 and 43 000 human
genes.
During 2003, when a 99% complete human genome sequence and a
Tetraodon assembly covering 90% of the genome were available,
Genoscope undertook a new evaluation of the number of human genes
using Exofish. This time, the average number of ecores per gene was
calculated from ecores present on five "finished" human chromosomes
(chromosomes 6, 13, 14, 20 and 22), for which the annotation had been
validated by human experts. From the number of ecores obtained for the
ensemble of the human genome sequence, a first estimate of the total
number of genes is deduced and corrected for the fraction of ecores
which detect pseudogenes. This calculation leads to a human gene
number ranging from 22 500 to 29 500, in good agreement with the above
annotation results (
Jaillon et al.,
2004).
 Comparison of the human gene SPAG7, encoding a sperm protein,
with the orthologous gene in Tetraodon nigroviridis.
The gene is eight times smaller in the fish, but exhibits the same exon
structure. The difference resides in the intron size, especially
in the first intron which is 6867 pb in human and 628 pb
in the fish. The decrease in intergenic distances also contributes
to the compactness of the Tetraodon genome. |
The ecores obtained by human-
Tetraodon comparisons (accessible
with the
Comparative
Genoscope browser) have been used in the annotation procedure for
several human chromosomes which have been published to date (beginning
of 2004). Despite these efforts, about 15 000 ecores remain outside of
all annotations (genes or pseudogenes) of the human genome sequence as
of spring 2004. These have served to define
904
new human gene models using gene models corresponding to these
ecores in
Tetraodon. More than 60% of these new putative genes,
which were probably not detected previously because of their small
size, have been confirmed by expression data.
When Exofish is utilized to compare genome sequences from
Tetraodon with those of other mammals such as the rat and the
mouse, the same ecores are detected as in the human
genome. Conversely, the ecores produced by comparing genomes of
humans, mouse and Takifugu with the genome of
Tetraodon have
helped in the identification of the genes of this little fish (for the
annotation procedure, see the
Sequencing
project page).
Up
History of the sequencing
project
The
Tetraodon nigroviridis sequencing project started in 1997
at Genoscope. It was an internal project, which was defined and
implemented at the very beginning of the center's activity. At this
time, the only vertebrate for which complete sequencing was planned
was the human genome: the mouse sequencing project was initiated only
in 1999 and the sequencing of
Takifugu rubripes began at the
end of 2000. The choice of
Tetraodon nigroviridis as a
sequencing target - a fish with a compact genome which was more
convenient than Takifugu to maintain in captivity - was thus initially
motivated by the need for a comparative genomics tool for the
exploration of the human genome that could be obtained quickly and
cheaply. The sequence data produced in this first random shotgun
sequencing phase (0.3 genome equivalents) could thus be successfully
used for a large-scale comparison with the human genome in 2000,
indicating the existence of about 30 000 genes in humans (see previous
section). In parallel with this random sequencing approach, regions of
special interest (genes of the immune system) were integrally
sequenced at Genoscope after selecting the corresponding genomic
inserts in BAC clones.
The project was next oriented toward producing a sequence of the
Tetraodon genome that would be as complete as possible,
pursuing the whole genome shotgun strategy at high depth. The new
objectives - a detailed analysis of the
Tetraodon proteome, the
organization of its genome and the regions syntenic with other
vertebrate genomes - required a high quality assembly. In June 2001,
the Whitehead Institute Center for Genome Research (WICGR, now the
Broad
Institute of MIT and Harvard) joined forces with Genoscope in this
effort. Around half of the reads were undertaken by the WICGR, so that
the project was considerably accelerated. Thus at the end of 2001, six
genome equivalents had been produced (2.3 Gb of raw sequence), with
each center contributing about half the sequences (see
press
release). This was a large enough amount of sequence data to
enable a first attempt at assembly at Genoscope (70% of the genome
covered by about one hundred thousand contigs). Two additional genome
equivalents were subsequently produced by Genoscope.
Eventually the total of 8.3 genome equivalents was assembled in
2002. The resulting draft (about 50 000 contigs linked in more than 25
000 supercontigs, or scaffolds) covers 90% of the euchromatic regions
of
Tetraodon and presents better long-range contiguity than the
genomic draft of Takifugu. Using data from physical mapping, 39
"ultracontigs", representing 64% of the sequence assembly, could be
anchored on the 21 chromosomes of
Tetraodon (see
their
distribution on the karyotype). This is the first time that an
overview of the organization of a fish genome has been available on a
chromosome scale. Annotation of the draft sequence at Genoscope has
produced 27 918 gene models. For more details on the assembly and
annotation, see the
Sequencing
project page and the article in
Nature, October 2004 (
Jaillon et al., 2004).
Up
Genomic landscape of
Tetraodon
One of the first lessons of the draft genomic sequence of
Tetraodon was the confirmation of the small size of this
genome. The 26 000 scaffolds which form the assembly cover 342 Mb
(gaps included). The 312 Mb of sequence that they contain represents
90% of the euchromatin of
Tetraodon (as measured with a set of
random reads), which can thus be evaluated at 346 Mb.
 global
distribution of the duplicated genes on the 21 Tetraodon
chromosomes. Genes on one chromosome segment have a strong tendency to
possess duplicate copies on a single other chromosome. This pattern is
very clear between chromosomes 9 and 11 |
On the other hand, the total size of the 21 chromosomes which constitute this
genome has been estimated to fall between 329 to 356 Mb by flux
cytometry. Thus the heterochromatic regions seem to be limited. This
extreme compactness explains why the percentage of GC base pairs (GC%)
of the genome of
Tetraodon is higher than that of large
mammalian genomes, as this percentage is positively correlated with
the gene density in vertebrates. However, the distribution of GC%
produces the same type of asymmetric bell curve - which indicates
a non-homogeneous distribution of genes - as that found in humans
and mice; it is only shifted toward the higher values. In
Takifugu
rubripes, however, the distribution of GC% is homogeneous. This
striking difference between the genomes of two closely related species
might be explained by sequencing or assembly defects in a (G+C)-rich
fraction of the genome of
Takifugu.
The genomic sequence has also made it possible to perform a detailed
study of the diversity and abundance of transposable elements in
Tetraodon. As expected, these are rare in this compact genome:
about 4000 copies were detected in unassembled sequences, at least
3.8% of the genome. However, they are also quite diverse :
75
consensus sequences (see Table 3) could be reconstituted (53 class
I elements and 22 class II elements, representing a large variety of
families), whereas only about 20 different types have been defined
from the millions of copies present in the human and mouse
genomes. Some families seem to still be active. In order to explain
the record rarity of transposable elements in
Tetraodon, it
must be postulated that they have experienced an unusually high level
of deletion. The transposable elements are concentrated in
heterochromatic regions, in particular on the short arms of the small
chromosomes. In euchromatic regions, there is a preferenial presence
of SINEs (short interspersed elements) in (A+T)-rich regions and of
LINEs (long interspersed elements) in (G+C)-rich regions, which is the
opposite of what is observed in mammals.
Up
The gene repertoire of
Tetraodon
Annotation of the genomic sequence of
Tetraodon has led to the
definition of 27 918 models of protein-encoding genes. This
number is of the same order as that found in humans. On a very global
scale, the results of Exofish analysis (see above) confirm this
result. We have compared the genomic sequences of four vertebrates
(
Takifugu,
Tetraodon, mouse and human), using each in
turn as a target, and obtained a similar number of evolutionary
conserved regions (ecores). However, these ecores could just as well
correspond to pseudogenes as genes, and we know that pseudogenes are
much less frequent in
Tetraodon and
Takifugu than in
mammals. This implies that these fish possess slightly more
protein-coding genes than mammals.
Genes represent 40% of the
Tetraodon genome. There are an
average of 6.9 coding exons per gene, and the size distribution of the
exons is similar to that observed in humans. On the contrary, the size
distribution of the introns is clearly different. The lower size limit
for introns is the same in both vertebrates (between 50 and 60 bp),
but there are many more introns which approach this lower limit in
Tetraodon than in humans. This phenomenon only concerns a
sub-population of
Tetraodon genes, however. It is unclear why
some genes have evolved toward reduction in intron size whereas others
do not seem to be affected.
A special effort was made to identify genes which pose problems in
annotation (see the
"Sequencing
project" page). This is notably the case for genes encoding type
I cytokines and their receptors, whose sequences are poorly conserved
in vertebrates. None of these genes were found at first in the
Takifugu genome, and it was justified to ask whether this large
gene family which includes hormones and interleukins is absent in
fish. In the
Tetraodon genome, we discovered 39 genes from all
gene families known in vertebrates. Comparison with the latter
indicates that, since the last common ancestor of
Tetraodon and
mammals, diversification has been especially strong on hormone systems
(growth hormones and prolactin) in the Actinpterygian lineage
(ray-finned fish), whereas it has operated more strongly on
interleukins in the mammalian lineage.
The global comparison between the proteome of
Tetraodon and
those of other sequenced vertebrates (
Takifugu, human, mouse)
and of the sea squirt
Ciona intestinalis (an invertebrate
chordate) has been instructive. Analysis of the protein domains using
InterPro revealed only a few differences between fish and mammals, but
some of these are of particular interest:
- The collagen molecules are a lot more diverse in fish than in mammals.
- Some domains which are associated with sodium transport are a lot more frequent in the fish and in Ciona, which reflects the fact that they live in salt water.
- Nucleosidases specific for purines are also more abundant in fish.
- Transcriptional repressors with the KRAB box, of which there
are hundreds in mammals, are completely absent in the fish.
If the frequency of various functional categories is compared based on
"Gene Ontology" classifications, again, few differences are found. The
two fish and
Ciona tend to differ as a group from the ensemble
of mammals; they exhibit a higher frequency of enzymatic and transport
functions, and a lower frequency of structural proteins and proteins
implicated in signal transduction.
Up
Evolutionary aspects (1):
neutral evolution rate and evolution rate of the coding DNA
The availability of the genomic sequences of humans and mice on one
hand, and
Takifugu and
Tetraodon on the other, provides
new opportunities for the study of the evolution of
vertebrates. Initially, we studied the rate at which these sequences
have diverged in the course of evolution, at the level of DNA with no
functional constraints.
When one is to study the rate of neutral evolution between two
vertebrate lineages which are as far apart as teleost fish and
mammals, it is not possible to identify ancestral repeated sequences
as can be done with humans and mice. We have therefore turned to the
freely mutable positions in genes inherited in common by the four
species. The first step was thus to define an ensemble of 5802
quadruplets of orthologous genes. Within these orthologs, we then
studied the third positions of some codons which are "fourfold
degenerate" ? that is, the third base of these codons can be
substituted by any of the three other possible bases without altering
the nature of the encoded amino acid and is therefore "free" to
change. This study has confirmed the neutral nucleotide substitution
rate which was previously measured using a smaller number of orthologs
between humans and mice; it has also shown that the level of neutral
evolution between the two fish was 2.5 times higher than between the
two mammals.
We then studied the level of divergence of protein sequences, by
comparing the sequences of the same ensemble of orthologs. The average
similarity is less between orthologous proteins of
Takifugu and
Tetraodon than between proteins of humans and
mice. Furthermore, the lineages of the two fish have not been
separated for as long as those of the two mammals. Thus, the protein
sequences have diverged faster in the fish, as has already been
observed using a smaller sample of genes. A comparison with a close
relative of the vertebrates - the sea squirt
Ciona
intestinalis - confirms this result: the frequency of
mutations which cause the substitution of one amino acid for another
(Ka) is higher on average between
Ciona and
Tetraodon
than between
Ciona and humans. Furthermore, the ratio between
non-synonymous (Ka) and synonymous (Ks) substitutions is also higher
between the two fish than between the two mammals. Since the last
common ancestor of pufferfish and mammals, evolution has thus
accelerated in the first group, or else slowed down in the second
lineage.
 How to pass from the bony vertebrate's last common ancestor
genome (12 chromosomes) to the genomes of humans and Tetraodon. Model derived from
the study of synteny groups between those two modern vertebrates |
Up
Evolutionary aspects (2):
Duplication of the genome
Recent studies have supported the hypothesis of the duplication of the
entire genome in the lineage of ray-finned fishes. An ancient whole
genome duplication (WGD), followed by a massive loss of duplicated
genes, has already been demonstrated in yeasts. Such events may be a
very important mechanism in the evolution of eukaryotic genomes. We
therefore looked for the trace of a WGD in the
Tetraodon
genome. The
Tetraodon genome sequence presents a unique
advantage for this type of research: it is the first genome of a fish
for which the available assembly is, in large part, anchored on the
chromosomes. For the first time, we can study the distribution of
duplicated genes at the global level, with the goal of determining
whether there was a sudden leap to the tetraploid state, or whether
there was a serie of discrete duplication events.
We have thus identified more than 1000 pairs of duplicated genes in
Tetraodon, and almost 1000 in
Takifugu. About 75% of the
duplication events seem to have happened before the separation of
Takifugu and
Tetraodon lineages. The distribution of
these ancient gene duplications is striking: copies of genes present
on a given chromosomal segment are all present on a single other
chromosome, and this pattern is found for the ensemble of
chromosomes. The simplest way to explain this finding is to suppose
that the whole genome has been duplicated in a single event. The
conservation of this tetraploid organization over the hundreds of
millions of years since the duplication could be due to the high
density of genes in the
Tetraodon genome: chromosome
rearrangements would be more detrimental than in mammals, because they
would be more likely to interfere with gene expression.
Up
Evolutionary aspects (3):
Synteny between the genomes of Tetraodon and of
mammals
A study of the distribution of orthologous genes between the genome of
Tetraodon and those of humans and mice has provided the
definitive evidence in favor of the WGD, and therefore ended the
controversy on this subject. Again, the anchorage of a large part of
the
Tetraodon genome sequence on the chromosome has been the
key factor: it has made it possible to produce the first high
resolution synteny map between fish and mammals. From 6684
Tetraodon genes of known position with an ortholog in the human
genome, we have defined 900 synteny groups (groups composed of at
least two contiguous
Tetraodon genes for which the orthologs
are situated on the same human chromosome). In the same way, 6831
Tetraodon genes with mouse orthologs have been organized into
1014 synteny groups. The fact that the synteny groups are more
numerous with mice than with humans confirms the higher frequency of
chromosome rearrangements in rodents.
Up
Evolutionary aspects (4): The
ancestral bony vertebrate genome
We have utilized these synteny findings to reconstitute the ancestral
organization of the genome at the moment of divergence of the
ray-finned fishes lineage. After duplication of this ancestral genome,
the supernumerary copies of the genes would have been lost at random
on one chromosome or the other in a duplicated pair. We would
therefore expect to find genes derived from a same ancestral
chromosome on two different modern chromosomes. The investigation of
the syntenic relations with the human genome effectively confirms this
binary distribution: the orthologs of genes of a given chromosomal
region in humans are found, for the most part, on two different
chromosomes of
Tetraodon. This provides an independent
demonstration of the duplication of the whole genome, but is also a
much more powerful strategy than the study of duplicated genes for
delimiting the duplicated chromosome segments and reconstituting the
fusion and fragmentation events. We propose that there were 12
chromosomes in the ancestral genome. This result is consistent with
the modal value for the haploid number of chromosomes in Teleosts,
which is 24. The 24 chromosomes formed by the duplication in the
Teleost lineage underwent 5 fusions, 3 translocations and 2
fragmentations to produce the 21 chromosomes of the
Tetraodon
genome.
On the evolutionary path leading to humans, the interchromosomic
rearrangements were more frequent. This reflects the large increase in
the number of repeated sequences in this lineage. In the resulting
"swollen" genomes, less dense in genes, rearrangements could happen
more frequently as they were less deleterious. It is even possible to
evaluate the relative age of these events: the genes present on two
ancestral segments that were joigned long ago would have been mixed
and homogenized by intrachromosomal rearrangements on the whole length
of the new chromosome; on the contrary, the genes present on newly
joigned segments would be more clearly seggregated. It is thus
possible to detect, for example, the recent fusion wich led to the
human chromosome 2, from two chromosomes that remain distinct in the
chimpanzee. In a near future, the sequencing of the genomes of other
vertebrates and of the amphioxus, closest living parent of the
vertebrates, will allow further exploration of the history of this
chromosomal mosaic.
Up
The sequencing of the genome of
Tetraodon nigroviridis is one of
Genoscope's internal projects. In 2001, the
Broad Institute
of MIT and Harvard (formerly the Whitehead Institute Centre for Genome
Research) has joined the project and has produced a substantial part of the
reads. The assembly step has also been performed in collaboration with the
Broad Institute. Several groups have contributed to the analysis and the
annotation of the genomic sequence of
Tetraodon nigroviridis:
- Laboratoire de
Biologie Moléculaire de la Cellule, CNRS UMR 5161, INRA UMR 1237,
Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon ;
- Service de
Systématique Moléculaire, CNRS IFR 101, dans le Département
Systématique et Evolution du Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle,
Paris ;
-
Défenses Antivirales et Antitumorales, CNRS UMR 5124, Montpellier ;
-
Grup de Recerca d'Informàtica Biomèdica, IMIM-UPF et
Programa de Bioinformàtica i Genòmica à Barcelone ;
-
Biométrie et Biologie Evolutive, CNRS UMR 5558, University Lyon 1 ;
-
Laboratoire des Interactions Plantes-Microorganismes, INRA UMR 441,
CNRS UMR 2594, Toulouse ;
- Agencourt,
Massachusetts, Etats-Unis ;
-
Groupe "Evolutionary Fish Genomics", Biozentrum, Université de Würzburg, Allemagne.
Bibliography
- R. Hinegardner, Am. Nat. (1968) 102, 517-563.
- S. Brenner et al., Nature (1993) 366, 265-268.
- T. Crnogorac-Jurcevic et al., Genomics (1997) 41, 177-184.
- B. Ewing & P. Green, Nature Genet. (2000) 25, 232-234.
- S. Aparicio et al., Science (2002) 297, 1301-1310.
- K.L. Howe et al., Genome Res. (2002) 12, 1418-1427.
- D.E. Neafsey et S.R. Palumbi, Genome Res. (2003) 13, 821-830.
Tetraodon articles that stemmed from the work of Genoscope's collaborators:
- H. Roest Crollius et al., Characterization and repeat analysis of the compact genome of the freshwater pufferfish Tetraodon nigroviridis. Genome Res. (2000) 10, 939-949.
- H. Roest Crollius et al., Human gene number estimate provided by genome wide analysis using Tetradon nigroviridis genomic DNA, Nature Genet. (2000) 25, 235-238.
- C. Dasilva et al., Remarkable compartimentalization of transposable elements and pseudogenes in the heterochromatine of the Tetraodon nigroviridis genome. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA (2002) 99, 13636-13641.
- F. Grützner et al., Four-hundred million years of conserved synteny of human Xp and Xq genes on three Tetraodon chromosomes. Genome Res. (2002) 12, 1316-1322.
- L. Bouneau et al., An active non-LTR retrotransposon with tandem structure in the compact genome of the pufferfish Tetraodon nigroviridis. Genome Res. (2003) 13, 1686-95.
- G. Lutfalla et al., Comparative genomic analysis reveals independant expansion of a lineage-specific gene family in vertebrates: the class II cytokine receptors and their ligands in mammals and fish. BMC Genomics (2003) 4, 29.
- J.N. Volff et al., Diversity of retrotransposable elements in compact pufferfish genomes. Trends Genet. (2003) 19, 674-678.
- O. Jaillon et al., Genome
duplication in the teleost fish Tetraodon nigroviridis reveals the early vertebrate proto-karyotype. Nature (2004) 431, 946-957.